Sunday, 26 February 2012

The Global Business Strategy Help Reduce Tax Bills of Multinational Companies

The tax payment has always been an important issue amongst a corporation's strategy. Corporations have the responsibility to its owners, the shareholders, to avoid tax legally. The tax planning for wholly domestic companies is simple, while it has many options for multinational companies. Nowadays increasingly more multinational companies are changing their strategies mainly for reducing tax because the more profits a company earns, the more tax burden it bears. 

Corporate tax takes a heavy proportion of all the company's tax bill. Multinationals in UK have found several approaches to avoid the relatively high tax rate of UK, which is 28%. For example, some companies like Shire's have moved the Head Office to Ireland, where the corporate tax rate is only 12.5%. Some companies use their foreign subsidiaries to reduce the profit in the high tax rate areas and transfer these profits to low tax rate areas. Some others like Tesco may achieve this using joint venture. But are these strategies always right and safe for a multinational's all aspects?

The 2011 February saw an uncomfortable tax affair of Barclays Group. Barclays revealed that it paid £113m corporate tax to UK in 2009, which is only 2.4% of its £4.6bn global profits in that year. Further more, the profit did not include the £6.3bn windfall gain from the sale of "ishares" business in April 2009. It immediately became a shocking news that angered both the public and the government. Public took a sit-in in its central London branch and Mr Umunna from the Treasury Selected Committee requested more details and said the bank was not paying its fair share towards a deficit they had helped create, despite having benefited from the government's rescue of the financial system. Barclays said the amount of corporation tax it paid for the year included losses for the previous year.

According to its financial result, Barclays paid an "effective tax rate" of 23% which comprised corporation tax paid in all its global markets, compares with the UK 28% corporation tax. About 60% profits of Barclays are from outside of UK and Ireland. The bank boss said it paid £2bn in taxes to the Revenue, but included the  income tax and national insurance contributions paid on employees' salaries. Even so, the level Barclays paid is actually remarkably low, according to Justin Urquhart-Stewart of Seven Investment Management. The £113m in corporation tax is only 6% of the £2bn total paid to the Revenue whilst the bonus pool amounted £3.4bn. "As a result of negotiations, banks will pay less in bonuses, more in tax and lend more than they otherwise would have done this year." Tory MP Matt Hancock said. According to an agreement with the big four UK banks - dubbed "Project Merlin" - they will contribute £10bn in tax, up from £8bn last year.

Through this Barclays tax avoid planning case, I may answer the question at the last of paragraph 2. Although using the geographic business strategy to avoid tax is legitimate and is a responsible means to generate shareholders' wealth, some highly public and government related multinationals, like banks, should be more prudent and more moral towards this. They should handle the balance well. They could give up some tax reducing planning and strategies and loss some competitive advantage in tax aspect, but through this they can build a strong corporate reputation in public and nation and that would bring much more profit since the public power and national support means a lot to them.

The Barclays case also indicates that in the past few years, the UK government failed to take robust action towards the fair shares like tax that should be contributed by banks, which took a big part of responsibility in the economic crash. Barclays is surely not the only bank that avoid large amount of tax through global business profit distribution. UK government and related authorities should be more aware of the damages that it brings to the nation's economy and take powerful and effective action before it is too late. 

News come from BBC News at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12511912
                                                   http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12514995


No comments:

Post a Comment