Sunday, 29 April 2012

C&WC Halves Dividend to Cover Investment Needs

Dividend policy is another important issue which is related to the shareholders' wealth. It is linked tightly to the capital structure and financing decisions made by senior managers. So we cannot separate them when discussing the dividend issues in companies. the future investment plan and cash flow of a company influence the dividend payout.

Cable and Wireless Communications (C&WC) is a global company that mainly provides services of mobile, broadband and fixed line. Financial Times reported in this April 18 that it is likely to cut its dividend at its full-year results next month to help retain cash in the UK-listed group to cover investment needs in its international telecoms business. It is considering cut the dividend payout from 8 cents a share for the full year 2012 to about 4 cents for 2013.

The reason is considered to be that earnings of C&WC had not grown substantially since last year, while the company wanted greater financial flexibility to match future investment costs as it positioned itself to provide next-generation mobile and fixed-line telecoms services. These investments are thought by managers to raise cash and support the global market scale for the company in the future.

This practical situation reflects the opinion of Millar & Modigliani: the dividend decision is essentially a financing decision. C&WC want to maximise the market value of the company through investing in positive NPV projects. In addition, according to the pecking order theory of Donaldson, using the dividend, which is the profit, instead of financing is the cheapest approach and is reasonable for the company did not do very well in the last two years.

However, in the actual practice, the dividend policy is always relevant to the share price. Analysts have said that some income funds have been selling stock in the company in anticipation of the dividend move, which has contributed to recent pressure on its share price. The shares have fallen about a third in the past three months, ending at about 30p a share at April 18. The share price decreased despite that the company is paying one of the highest dividend yields in the sector at about 16%, so a cut of half would reduce it in line with the sector average of 8%. This happened because that the shareholders did not know all the information about C&WC and its investment projects. C&WC also committed to an ambitious shareholder payout at the time of its demerger in 2010.

In my opinion, the dividend can influence the share price of a company. There is no perfect capital market and information cannot all be shared between the companies and shareholders. Making positive projects prior may result in fluctuate dividend payout. This could in some extent decrease the confidence of shareholders and influence the share price, although it may bring profit in long terms. I think C&WC should introduce a stable dividend policy. It should have not paid such a high dividend in 2010 when it is more profitable. Then, it should decrease its dividend step by step, but not cut a half suddenly in a year. Additionally, it can communicate the cutting reasons with the market and explain the investment projects to its shareholders to gain their confidence.



Reference: Financial Times: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/50b47b54-895f-11e1-85af-00144feab49a.html#axzz1tS5dpTyK

Thursday, 29 March 2012

Soho House: Benefit but also Suffer from High Gearing


The traditional theory of capital structure suggests companies to increase their gearing level as it is believed effective to lower the cost of capital and to bring values to companies and shareholders. But when the capital structure is too geared, the company should bear a large risk of financial distress and a heavy burden from paying the interest and the enormous principal when it is due to debtors. The Soho House Group has some implications for this situation.

The Soho House network of private members's clubs, restaurants and hotels is where the rich and famous go to see and be seen. But its financial structure is not as shiny as it appears.

Accounts filed in January 2011 for Soho House’s holding company, SHG Acquisition UK, show that the company’s balance sheet was stretched, with shareholders’ funds in deficit by £18m. Although the company accorded £54m of goodwill to the value of its Soho House trademark, it was nevertheless weighed down with £185m of gross debts, the majority provided by lender Halifax Bank of Scotland, which was subsequently taken over by Lloyds, and the accounts refer to two separate refinancings due in December 2011 and January 2013. Some of these loans were secured on the group’s freehold property assets - Babinton House in Somerset, and High Road House in west London. Accounts for SHG's 100 per cent-owned subsidiary Soho House Properties for the same period value these properties at £20.6m, a figure that tallies with valuations shown on Land Registry filings. However, its other property assets were generally leased, rather than owned outright. The company was also supported by shareholder loans of about £30m from Mr. Caring, Mr. Jones, and his wife, the BBC Desert Island Discs presenter Kirsty Young.

For the reason of keeping such a high gearing level, the large amount of its fashion and other expenditures is disclosed as the most concerned reason by group. Accounts filed for the Soho House group of companies make frequent reference to the high levels of capital expenditure that have been needed to keep up with its members’ high expectations. Aside from the cash-intensive nature of the business model, records lodged with Companies House show that prior to the deal, the company’s capital structure was far from ideal.

However, it make some sacrifice for holding enormous debts. In January 2012, the majority owners Richard Caring, the owner of a string of London restaurants, and the club’s founder Nick Jones announced they had sold a majority stake in the business to Ron Burkle, the US billionaire. Mr. Burkle’s investment fund, Yucaipa, had ascribed an enterprise value of £250m to the group’s global network of clubs. However, it is not clear how the £105m Mr. Caring paid to take an 80 per cent stake in the group in 2008 could have turned into a business worth £250m four years later. The group reported a consolidated turnover of £85.6m for the 40 weeks to January 2 last year, and earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) of £11.9m. It seems that the £250m is hard to make because it is about 21 times of its earnings.

From the Soho House case, the traditional suggestions of increasing the debt level is doubted. In my opinion, the gearing level should be benchmarked among the same sector or same business, like the club business because each specific business has its own financial characteristics and its special demand for debt or equity. Normally, financiers suggests comapnies to stop increasing debt when the cost of debt is equal to the cost of equity. But I think Soho House and other similar business can borrow more debt than that boundary because of their operating nature. However, they should bear the risk and repaying burden in mind when they do so. Alternative approaches like cut additional cost is also important to the group and shareholders value.


Source:Financial Times http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/ee3120ea53ee11e19eac00144feabdc0.html#ixzz1qXpNKC1v

Sunday, 25 March 2012

SRI: Is It a Useful Tool to Benefit Both Society and Business?


Social Responsible Investment (SRI) is increasingly popular among the business world. SRI encourages investors to bring the social, ethical and environmental considerations into the portfolio of investing strategy. I think, in some extent, it can be a tool to benefit both the society and the business itself if enterprises use it appropriately, especially in nowadays Great Recession environment of financial market. In addition, governments are also promoting this investment form by setting new legislation and different tax regulations, to solve the jobless and other similar situations.


Because the 2007-2008 financial crisis destroyed the credit of many large and small businesses in America, the fully recovery is a tough and long process. Government turned to the SRI as a means to release the society and economic pressure. The USA lawmakers are considering a bill that would allow for the creation of a new corporate entity called a social enterprise business that would shield a firm’s executive management from shareholder lawsuits if they put pursuing a social cause ahead of maximizing profits. This proposal goes further than any other laws exists in America because it calls for restrictions on excessive executive compensation and requires a living wage to be paid to a company’s employees. More significantly, it requires a business to state a public benefit mission in its incorporation articles, and gives equal priority to the interests of a company’s shareholders, employees, customers, as well as community and social considerations and the environment. That’s different from a typical corporation which is legally bound to put shareholder interests ahead of all other parties.


Perhaps Starbucks takes the SRI actions a big step prior than what the US government advocated. Howard Schultz, the chairman and chief executive of Starbucks, started to create programmes to invest in social concerned projects in 2011. These programmes were almost nothing about its coffee business, but socially responsible. One of them is the 'Create Jobs for USA'. Schultz knew that small businesses created most new jobs, but that many small business people couldn't hire because they had lost access to credit after the financial crisis. Starbucks, as the middleman, using its sheer size, would find financial institutions willing to loan to small businesses. Starbucks customers would be able to donate money to the effort when they bought their coffee. Those who gave $5 or more would get a red-white-and-blue wristband. It found a financial partner Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) as lenders and the Opportunity Finance Network as an umbrella group to the best of them. CDFIs are most nonprofit, and their loan default rates are extremely low. Starbucks and the Starbucks Foundation would pay for the marketing costs, the wristbands and every other cost associated with the new program. The donations to Create Jobs for USA woud not be loaned to the CDFIs. They would be turned into capital — equity that can be leveraged 7 to 1, meaning that if 10 million Starbucks customers donate $5, that would support $350 million worth of lending. The Starbucks Foundation would invest initially $5 million. The idea was innovated from Starbucks' microlending programme in some countries. 


However, SRI should also be used carefully and appropriately by corporations. In March 2012, at the annual shareholders meeting, Howard Schultz expected to crystallise the connection between Starbucks' profit and its social responsibility role. But he was questioned by shareholders that how do they sell high-priced coffee in a such crowded market. What's more, some groups targeted Starbucks partly because the company puts forward an image of being socially responsible and a good corporate citizen. Using these clauses to squash customers' legal rights is not an indication of being a good corporate citizen. These might be the disharmonious things towards Schultz's believe: companies expressing a socially responsible posture can ultimately create value for themselves. 


In my opinion, I tend to support Mr. Schultz's moral capitalism view. Concerning about social and environmental issues when choosing investment scenario is equally profitable with the traditional investment method in a long term. In addition, it can build differentiate brand in a market. Starbucks' share price has increased 57% from 35.16 in August 2011 to 55.35 in 2012 March. This is an evidence to support the equal return opinion, although profitability cannot be measured only by share price. Newground Socail Investment in Seattle, who invested in Starbucks, commented in March that Starbucks are a lot more open and accountable and transparent than they used to be. This shows a brand and market appreciation toward SRI. However, It would be more successful of this SRI programme if Starbucks take customers' emotion towards high price into account at first step. Starbucks could have applied this programme in some certain areas in America first and then progressively spread it. It seems that SRI is a win-win tool for both society and companies, if it is used strategically.


Source: The Wall Street Journal
               The New York Times
               The Seattle Times

Sunday, 18 March 2012

Credit Crunch: It Really Damaged the Small Business Other than Bank Industry


This week, I am going to talk about the impact of credit crunch in financial crisis, preparing the four questions in next seminar. These four questions limited the influences of credit crunch in a very small range of groups, only of banks, America, and large business. The cases will be expressed to argue and against the opinion. 

The credit crunch, which resulted in the serous financial crisis during 2007-2008, do damage the wealth of small companies other than bank industry. The reason is apparent. Even the small companies have a certain amount of deposits in banks and loans borrowed from banks. Many investment banks as well as some commercial banks became collapsed and nationalised. Small businesses could hardly withdraw or maintain the value of their money in the banks, neither could they continuous to set sufficient amount of loan contracts with banks further. Since the small firms are limited by the economic scale and business scope, the liquidity of them is usually at a lower level, and the financial damage defense system of them is much weaker than large corporations. What's more, small companies usually would not distribute their investment in a wide range as they do not obtain such complicated and comprehensive investment plan. As a result, some crises of high-reputation financial services companies like Wamu and Fannie Mae would make small businesses suffer a lot. 

In September 2008 in Ohio, banks were refusing to renew lines of credit and calling in loans made to decades-old family businesses that are current on payments, according to Dayton bankruptcy and workout attorney John Rieser. He said it's the worst borrowing environment he had seen in 20 years. The pullback began early in 2008 and accelerated later. "They're pulling the triggers and saying you're done," Rieser said. "It's not just sick businesses. These are healthy businesses, and that's the surprising thing." One of Rieser's clients, Tom Rajkovich, says he had a $340,000 balance on his commercial mortgage and $260,000 drawn on a line of credit from Chase (JPM) when the bank demanded repayment in the summer of 2007, saying he had failed to send financial reports required by his loan agreement. Rajkovich's six-employee company, Comet Automation Systems in Dayton, manufactures and imports plastics machinery and is heavily tied to the auto industry. 

Lending standards for small businesses have been tightening at many banks for more than a year, according to the Federal Reserve's latest available quarterly survey of senior loan officers. In the three months ending in July, 65% of banks said they tightened credit for companies with less than $50 million in revenue. Lenders say they see companies tied to the housing industry—everyone from mortgage brokers to furniture makers—as particularly risky. 

In UK in 2007, when the credit crunch boomed later, the Federal of Small Business (FSB) said that some of its members were borrowing at between 10% and 11% - more than two percentage points above the rates they had previously been able to get. The FSB, which represents about 210,000 UK firms, added that there was a broader concern that small businesses would not be able to afford to expand. 

Therefore, although small businesses are often overlooked by financial markets as they has less influences towards it than large multinationals, they paid for the financial crisis a lot. This phenomenon also impacted the society and economy of countries because small businesses have a close link to the increase of underemployment rate, as well as the economic and politic stable of a country. In my opinion, some feasible approaches like improving the credit degree and accountability of small corporations, seeking alternative investment directions, and planning a risk-based auditing or internal control scenario is immediately needed for small businesses. 







Sunday, 11 March 2012

Post-M&A Integration Influences Return and Shareholders Wealth

The past two years saw a large amount of merger and acquisition activities between companies driven by consolidation strategy, cost-saving economic scale and the most important--attractive market power.  The Wall Street reported in August 2011 that the volume of worldwide M&A transactions has reached $1.8 trillion, a 31% increase year by year. M&A is a good way to help large firms break entry barriers into the new market, as well as establish dominant market position.

However, a large proportion of M&A deals failed to deliver the expected benefits to shareholders. According to Quantisoft, a specialist in measuring integration success, two thirds of M&A deals failed to achieve the expected returns due to a combined lack of adequate cultural, leadership, process, technology and product integration. The integration condition of a new merged company can influences the customers and potential investors' choices. It also has an impact on companies' public appearance. Therefore, building a well integrated company can maintain or increase the existing shareholders' wealth, or vice versa. The integration after merger is mostly mentioned by the identity, cooperation and restructure of two companies, like the logo and culture of the new combined firm.

Here is a successful example of merger of United Airlines and Continental Airlines in October 2010, which was completed in March 3 this year. Both companies were full-service airlines and had faced intense competition from low-cost operators. United Airlines' parent company UAL reported a loss of $82m for the first three months of the year, after reporting a $1.1bn loss for 2009. Continental also reported a $282m loss in the same year. Those may be the reason of this desired merger. The deal worth $3.2bn (£2.1bn) and would bring savings of more than $1bn a year. After announcement, United's parent UAL Corporation saw its shares rise by 51 cents, or 2.37%, to close in New York at $22.11, while Continental shares were up 51 cents, or 2.28%, to $22.86. Shareholders in the two airlines overwhelmingly voted to approve the deal in September 2011.


The new planes will fly under the United Airlines name. Although the United is seen as the dominant partner at this deal, it was described as "a merger of equals". The new United logo is simply the old Continental logo with a different word in front of the disco ball-like globe symbol. Only the actual letters themselves are from United -- the font, color, symbol and lockup are purely Continental. For someone glancing at the logo quickly, Continental would register in his or her mind. United's description of the new logo doesn't betray much strategic thought process or market research behind the new logo choice. It states, "the globe symbolizes our combined worldwide network spanning six continents and serving more than 370 global destinations." Continental's chief executive Jeff Smisek will take on the same position at his new corporation. In February 2012, UAL's stock increased to $26.84, the highest for last few years.

In my opinion, promoting and enhancing the identity of the merged companies are fundamental and essential to a well-organised integration condition. But it is always overlooked by many firms. A good identity can be illustrated by their cooperation in structural development, employees' position changing and the agreement of corporate culture and logo by both side. Only in that integrated way can a merged company be successful. It is a long-term beneficial action which should be taken in the first place.   

Sources come from: BBC News at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10095080
                                                      http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-11353161
                               The Street at http://www.thestreet.com/story/11431058/1/for-post-merger-takeoff-a-logo-needs-lift.html
                               Director of Finance at http://www.dofonline.co.uk/content/view/6051/115/

Sunday, 4 March 2012

What Dose Foreign Direct Investment Bring?

One of the most impartant issues that faced by many transnational companies may be the global-based investment strategy. Foreign direct investment (FDI) plays a significant role in this activities since the domestic opportunities are often limited and expansion is most successful companies' goal. There are two major means to achieve FDI, first is greenfield investment. Companies usually set subsidiaries and factories in a chosen country. This need a big money. They can also provide finance, brand and technology to a company of that country. The second way is through international mergers and acquisitions activities. Many corporates do this to expand their market shares. 

Under the learnning and searching real cases in this week, I think FDI can be seen as a win-win approach between transnational companies and the host countries. Through opening subsidiaries or investing in profitable projects in the host countries, corporates can generate a large amount of return. It is also a good way to entry a new market or industry. In the host countries' side, they can find a way to use the business opportunities to attract cash from the globe, which would be important to boost domestic economy. For this reason, many governments of developing countries have policis to support this attractive activity.

This phenomenon--developed giant companies investing in developng countries-- was very popular in the recent decades, especially in technology-based industry like Microsoft and Sony, ensurance industry like Prudential and retail industry like Walmart. These companies were attracted by the the low cost raw materials and workers and the super markets in developing countries. However, this trend seems has changed a little in some areas like China. On the contrary, developing countries companies also invest directly in some developed countries. Increasing number of Chinese firms bought their western rivals, following the electronics firm Lenovo, which acquired IBM's computer business in 2005 for $1.75bn.

In January 2012, China's largest construction equipment group, Sany Heavy Industry, agreed to buy a 90% stake in German industrial firm Putzmeister for 324m euro, its first overseas acquisition. Prior to the deal, Sany's overseas sales made up just 4% of group revenue. In contrast, more than 80% of Putzmeister's revenue came from countries other than China. Through Sany's investment in Putzmeister, it increased its overseas sales four-fold, acquired a global distribution and service network, and positioned Sany to become a serious competitor to industry leaders such as Caterpillar and Komatsu.












Comparing the business scales between Sany and Putzmeister, it is easy to see that the biggest reason for Sany to do so is the market entry. New market means more customers and profit, as well as economy scale.
Sany can better compete its western competitors if it get more market from them. The second reason could be for technology buying. It is true that developed countries have the newest technology in heavy industry. And I think, for any acquisitions, there must be a reason for corporate diversification strategy, which is the key factors for keeping sustainable competitive capabilities.

But why this small trend exists? I think the first reason is the 2008 financial crisis and the Europe economy slowdown now. These event make the opportunity for good companies in developing countries to enter western market, which also need foreign investment to help to cope the situation. The second reason is that Sany is supported by government in both fiannce and policy. This acquisition can also bring beneffits for the government in addition to Sany itself. So, to conclud, as the European and US transnational companies directly investing in developing countries, FDI from developing world to western world can still be a win-win contract.

Sunday, 26 February 2012

The Global Business Strategy Help Reduce Tax Bills of Multinational Companies

The tax payment has always been an important issue amongst a corporation's strategy. Corporations have the responsibility to its owners, the shareholders, to avoid tax legally. The tax planning for wholly domestic companies is simple, while it has many options for multinational companies. Nowadays increasingly more multinational companies are changing their strategies mainly for reducing tax because the more profits a company earns, the more tax burden it bears. 

Corporate tax takes a heavy proportion of all the company's tax bill. Multinationals in UK have found several approaches to avoid the relatively high tax rate of UK, which is 28%. For example, some companies like Shire's have moved the Head Office to Ireland, where the corporate tax rate is only 12.5%. Some companies use their foreign subsidiaries to reduce the profit in the high tax rate areas and transfer these profits to low tax rate areas. Some others like Tesco may achieve this using joint venture. But are these strategies always right and safe for a multinational's all aspects?

The 2011 February saw an uncomfortable tax affair of Barclays Group. Barclays revealed that it paid £113m corporate tax to UK in 2009, which is only 2.4% of its £4.6bn global profits in that year. Further more, the profit did not include the £6.3bn windfall gain from the sale of "ishares" business in April 2009. It immediately became a shocking news that angered both the public and the government. Public took a sit-in in its central London branch and Mr Umunna from the Treasury Selected Committee requested more details and said the bank was not paying its fair share towards a deficit they had helped create, despite having benefited from the government's rescue of the financial system. Barclays said the amount of corporation tax it paid for the year included losses for the previous year.

According to its financial result, Barclays paid an "effective tax rate" of 23% which comprised corporation tax paid in all its global markets, compares with the UK 28% corporation tax. About 60% profits of Barclays are from outside of UK and Ireland. The bank boss said it paid £2bn in taxes to the Revenue, but included the  income tax and national insurance contributions paid on employees' salaries. Even so, the level Barclays paid is actually remarkably low, according to Justin Urquhart-Stewart of Seven Investment Management. The £113m in corporation tax is only 6% of the £2bn total paid to the Revenue whilst the bonus pool amounted £3.4bn. "As a result of negotiations, banks will pay less in bonuses, more in tax and lend more than they otherwise would have done this year." Tory MP Matt Hancock said. According to an agreement with the big four UK banks - dubbed "Project Merlin" - they will contribute £10bn in tax, up from £8bn last year.

Through this Barclays tax avoid planning case, I may answer the question at the last of paragraph 2. Although using the geographic business strategy to avoid tax is legitimate and is a responsible means to generate shareholders' wealth, some highly public and government related multinationals, like banks, should be more prudent and more moral towards this. They should handle the balance well. They could give up some tax reducing planning and strategies and loss some competitive advantage in tax aspect, but through this they can build a strong corporate reputation in public and nation and that would bring much more profit since the public power and national support means a lot to them.

The Barclays case also indicates that in the past few years, the UK government failed to take robust action towards the fair shares like tax that should be contributed by banks, which took a big part of responsibility in the economic crash. Barclays is surely not the only bank that avoid large amount of tax through global business profit distribution. UK government and related authorities should be more aware of the damages that it brings to the nation's economy and take powerful and effective action before it is too late. 

News come from BBC News at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12511912
                                                   http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12514995