Sunday, 11 March 2012

Post-M&A Integration Influences Return and Shareholders Wealth

The past two years saw a large amount of merger and acquisition activities between companies driven by consolidation strategy, cost-saving economic scale and the most important--attractive market power.  The Wall Street reported in August 2011 that the volume of worldwide M&A transactions has reached $1.8 trillion, a 31% increase year by year. M&A is a good way to help large firms break entry barriers into the new market, as well as establish dominant market position.

However, a large proportion of M&A deals failed to deliver the expected benefits to shareholders. According to Quantisoft, a specialist in measuring integration success, two thirds of M&A deals failed to achieve the expected returns due to a combined lack of adequate cultural, leadership, process, technology and product integration. The integration condition of a new merged company can influences the customers and potential investors' choices. It also has an impact on companies' public appearance. Therefore, building a well integrated company can maintain or increase the existing shareholders' wealth, or vice versa. The integration after merger is mostly mentioned by the identity, cooperation and restructure of two companies, like the logo and culture of the new combined firm.

Here is a successful example of merger of United Airlines and Continental Airlines in October 2010, which was completed in March 3 this year. Both companies were full-service airlines and had faced intense competition from low-cost operators. United Airlines' parent company UAL reported a loss of $82m for the first three months of the year, after reporting a $1.1bn loss for 2009. Continental also reported a $282m loss in the same year. Those may be the reason of this desired merger. The deal worth $3.2bn (£2.1bn) and would bring savings of more than $1bn a year. After announcement, United's parent UAL Corporation saw its shares rise by 51 cents, or 2.37%, to close in New York at $22.11, while Continental shares were up 51 cents, or 2.28%, to $22.86. Shareholders in the two airlines overwhelmingly voted to approve the deal in September 2011.


The new planes will fly under the United Airlines name. Although the United is seen as the dominant partner at this deal, it was described as "a merger of equals". The new United logo is simply the old Continental logo with a different word in front of the disco ball-like globe symbol. Only the actual letters themselves are from United -- the font, color, symbol and lockup are purely Continental. For someone glancing at the logo quickly, Continental would register in his or her mind. United's description of the new logo doesn't betray much strategic thought process or market research behind the new logo choice. It states, "the globe symbolizes our combined worldwide network spanning six continents and serving more than 370 global destinations." Continental's chief executive Jeff Smisek will take on the same position at his new corporation. In February 2012, UAL's stock increased to $26.84, the highest for last few years.

In my opinion, promoting and enhancing the identity of the merged companies are fundamental and essential to a well-organised integration condition. But it is always overlooked by many firms. A good identity can be illustrated by their cooperation in structural development, employees' position changing and the agreement of corporate culture and logo by both side. Only in that integrated way can a merged company be successful. It is a long-term beneficial action which should be taken in the first place.   

Sources come from: BBC News at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10095080
                                                      http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-11353161
                               The Street at http://www.thestreet.com/story/11431058/1/for-post-merger-takeoff-a-logo-needs-lift.html
                               Director of Finance at http://www.dofonline.co.uk/content/view/6051/115/

No comments:

Post a Comment