Thursday, 29 March 2012

Soho House: Benefit but also Suffer from High Gearing


The traditional theory of capital structure suggests companies to increase their gearing level as it is believed effective to lower the cost of capital and to bring values to companies and shareholders. But when the capital structure is too geared, the company should bear a large risk of financial distress and a heavy burden from paying the interest and the enormous principal when it is due to debtors. The Soho House Group has some implications for this situation.

The Soho House network of private members's clubs, restaurants and hotels is where the rich and famous go to see and be seen. But its financial structure is not as shiny as it appears.

Accounts filed in January 2011 for Soho House’s holding company, SHG Acquisition UK, show that the company’s balance sheet was stretched, with shareholders’ funds in deficit by £18m. Although the company accorded £54m of goodwill to the value of its Soho House trademark, it was nevertheless weighed down with £185m of gross debts, the majority provided by lender Halifax Bank of Scotland, which was subsequently taken over by Lloyds, and the accounts refer to two separate refinancings due in December 2011 and January 2013. Some of these loans were secured on the group’s freehold property assets - Babinton House in Somerset, and High Road House in west London. Accounts for SHG's 100 per cent-owned subsidiary Soho House Properties for the same period value these properties at £20.6m, a figure that tallies with valuations shown on Land Registry filings. However, its other property assets were generally leased, rather than owned outright. The company was also supported by shareholder loans of about £30m from Mr. Caring, Mr. Jones, and his wife, the BBC Desert Island Discs presenter Kirsty Young.

For the reason of keeping such a high gearing level, the large amount of its fashion and other expenditures is disclosed as the most concerned reason by group. Accounts filed for the Soho House group of companies make frequent reference to the high levels of capital expenditure that have been needed to keep up with its members’ high expectations. Aside from the cash-intensive nature of the business model, records lodged with Companies House show that prior to the deal, the company’s capital structure was far from ideal.

However, it make some sacrifice for holding enormous debts. In January 2012, the majority owners Richard Caring, the owner of a string of London restaurants, and the club’s founder Nick Jones announced they had sold a majority stake in the business to Ron Burkle, the US billionaire. Mr. Burkle’s investment fund, Yucaipa, had ascribed an enterprise value of £250m to the group’s global network of clubs. However, it is not clear how the £105m Mr. Caring paid to take an 80 per cent stake in the group in 2008 could have turned into a business worth £250m four years later. The group reported a consolidated turnover of £85.6m for the 40 weeks to January 2 last year, and earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) of £11.9m. It seems that the £250m is hard to make because it is about 21 times of its earnings.

From the Soho House case, the traditional suggestions of increasing the debt level is doubted. In my opinion, the gearing level should be benchmarked among the same sector or same business, like the club business because each specific business has its own financial characteristics and its special demand for debt or equity. Normally, financiers suggests comapnies to stop increasing debt when the cost of debt is equal to the cost of equity. But I think Soho House and other similar business can borrow more debt than that boundary because of their operating nature. However, they should bear the risk and repaying burden in mind when they do so. Alternative approaches like cut additional cost is also important to the group and shareholders value.


Source:Financial Times http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/ee3120ea53ee11e19eac00144feabdc0.html#ixzz1qXpNKC1v

No comments:

Post a Comment