Sunday, 25 March 2012

SRI: Is It a Useful Tool to Benefit Both Society and Business?


Social Responsible Investment (SRI) is increasingly popular among the business world. SRI encourages investors to bring the social, ethical and environmental considerations into the portfolio of investing strategy. I think, in some extent, it can be a tool to benefit both the society and the business itself if enterprises use it appropriately, especially in nowadays Great Recession environment of financial market. In addition, governments are also promoting this investment form by setting new legislation and different tax regulations, to solve the jobless and other similar situations.


Because the 2007-2008 financial crisis destroyed the credit of many large and small businesses in America, the fully recovery is a tough and long process. Government turned to the SRI as a means to release the society and economic pressure. The USA lawmakers are considering a bill that would allow for the creation of a new corporate entity called a social enterprise business that would shield a firm’s executive management from shareholder lawsuits if they put pursuing a social cause ahead of maximizing profits. This proposal goes further than any other laws exists in America because it calls for restrictions on excessive executive compensation and requires a living wage to be paid to a company’s employees. More significantly, it requires a business to state a public benefit mission in its incorporation articles, and gives equal priority to the interests of a company’s shareholders, employees, customers, as well as community and social considerations and the environment. That’s different from a typical corporation which is legally bound to put shareholder interests ahead of all other parties.


Perhaps Starbucks takes the SRI actions a big step prior than what the US government advocated. Howard Schultz, the chairman and chief executive of Starbucks, started to create programmes to invest in social concerned projects in 2011. These programmes were almost nothing about its coffee business, but socially responsible. One of them is the 'Create Jobs for USA'. Schultz knew that small businesses created most new jobs, but that many small business people couldn't hire because they had lost access to credit after the financial crisis. Starbucks, as the middleman, using its sheer size, would find financial institutions willing to loan to small businesses. Starbucks customers would be able to donate money to the effort when they bought their coffee. Those who gave $5 or more would get a red-white-and-blue wristband. It found a financial partner Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) as lenders and the Opportunity Finance Network as an umbrella group to the best of them. CDFIs are most nonprofit, and their loan default rates are extremely low. Starbucks and the Starbucks Foundation would pay for the marketing costs, the wristbands and every other cost associated with the new program. The donations to Create Jobs for USA woud not be loaned to the CDFIs. They would be turned into capital — equity that can be leveraged 7 to 1, meaning that if 10 million Starbucks customers donate $5, that would support $350 million worth of lending. The Starbucks Foundation would invest initially $5 million. The idea was innovated from Starbucks' microlending programme in some countries. 


However, SRI should also be used carefully and appropriately by corporations. In March 2012, at the annual shareholders meeting, Howard Schultz expected to crystallise the connection between Starbucks' profit and its social responsibility role. But he was questioned by shareholders that how do they sell high-priced coffee in a such crowded market. What's more, some groups targeted Starbucks partly because the company puts forward an image of being socially responsible and a good corporate citizen. Using these clauses to squash customers' legal rights is not an indication of being a good corporate citizen. These might be the disharmonious things towards Schultz's believe: companies expressing a socially responsible posture can ultimately create value for themselves. 


In my opinion, I tend to support Mr. Schultz's moral capitalism view. Concerning about social and environmental issues when choosing investment scenario is equally profitable with the traditional investment method in a long term. In addition, it can build differentiate brand in a market. Starbucks' share price has increased 57% from 35.16 in August 2011 to 55.35 in 2012 March. This is an evidence to support the equal return opinion, although profitability cannot be measured only by share price. Newground Socail Investment in Seattle, who invested in Starbucks, commented in March that Starbucks are a lot more open and accountable and transparent than they used to be. This shows a brand and market appreciation toward SRI. However, It would be more successful of this SRI programme if Starbucks take customers' emotion towards high price into account at first step. Starbucks could have applied this programme in some certain areas in America first and then progressively spread it. It seems that SRI is a win-win tool for both society and companies, if it is used strategically.


Source: The Wall Street Journal
               The New York Times
               The Seattle Times

No comments:

Post a Comment