In terms of the corporate objective, the majority contemporary theories prefer shareholders wealth maximization than other objectives such as sales maximization, profit maximization, market share dominance etc. Most US and UK companies are focusing on this objective to survive and compete in the markets. This objective makes them efficiency and better accountable for the owners.
However, the managerialism is an obstacle for the shareholder value creation. It is mostly because of the separation of ownership and control. Managers pursue the different thing with shareholders, but the shareholders normally have little involvement in the corporate management and governance.
In 2010, Calpers, the US largest public pension fund by asset, asked Apple to change the form of directors election (Financial Times). Calpers holds 0.2 per cent of Apple's stock and asked it, as well as other US technology group, to introduce the majority voting to directors election, aiming to improve the accountability to shareholders. Apple's present election form can make directors retain by just one vote in an uncontested election because the shareholders can only withhold their vote, rather than vote against. However, Apple refused this proposal. In the past Apple has been criticised by failure disclosure of the health situation of Steve Jobs or the eventual plans for succession.
In 2011, the two US public pension funds Calpers and Calstrs asked for better shareholders representation by improving the diversity and quality of corporate directors (Financial Times). They claimed that "proxy access" is a fundamental shareholder right and it is a way to ensure companies have the skills to success facing the global challenge. Anne Sheehan, the Calstrs director of corporate governance said US is "one of the few remaining large capital markets without majority vote in uncontested elections or proxy access".
Financial Times indicated at February 5, 2012 that Apple will face shareholders pressure at the annual meeting this mouth towards the way it elects directors. Calpers said Apple needs a governance upgrade. But this proposal is non-binding and refused by Apple for several times, which nullified what had had been seen as the "victory for shareholder rights".
Through this case, shareholder rights towards corporate governance are still very powerless even the company is under the objective of shareholder wealth maximization. Shareholders need to monitor a company more efficiently. One practical means is changing the traditional incentives motivation and measurement management. Afer all, a company should have efficient and up to date governance that can create shareholder value to compete till the last in addition to brand domination and unique high quality technology.
Do you have any solutions for this situation?
ReplyDeleteThe solution was mentioned several points referring to agency policy in the lecture. In conclude: issuing top manager shares (Apple already done this); changing incentive measurements; releasing new corporate regulation.
ReplyDelete