Raising finance is always a substantial task faced by finance managers. Companies need sufficient capital to support their business activities in order to survive and compete in the industry. There are two basic ways popularly uesd by contemporary corporations: issuing new shares in stock markets; borrowing debts by issuing bonds to banks or bond market. A healthy capital structure is important in not only providing capital but also balancing interest pressure. Thearfore, companies should choose the suitable type and the proportion of each type when they are raising capital.
Comparing these two approaches of financing capital, Companies might choose debt in most situation because it needs less amount of fee and less restrictions to undertake. The timing period is also shorter than issuing shares. However, the interest payment pressure can be large no matter companies profit or loss because the interest is fixed. Therefore, many big companies combine the two financing approaches to reduce the risk. But even under one way, say the equity finance, there are still different types of shares that have different expected returns of investment by investors. The situation is same in different forms of debts.
When raising capitals for an company activity, companies cost an amount of money to pay the fees and interests. A good tool to evaluate a project or programme is the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). Companies usually compare it with the eatimated return of a programme to make decisions. Normally, the return should be higher than the WACC to ensure company's cash flow and shareholders' wealth.
In March 2010, the UK insurance giant Prudential decided to take over AIA, which is an AIG's Asian unit, by $35bn. Prudential planed to part-fund the deal by a $20bn rights issue, which make the share prices down 72 pence at 530p, after hitting 515p at one point. BBC said this amount of rights issue ranked as one of the biggest cash calls by a company. It would also raise $5bn borrowings to fund this acquisition. However, the deal terminated later in June because AIG did not consider the revisions to the agreement terms. (BBC News, 2010)
Supposing that the acquisition successd at last, In my opinion, it will bring Prudential not only a better capital structure but also a expanded profitable market basing on the company and industry status. Firstly, the Gearing ratio for Prudential in 2009 is nearly 200%, which showed a slightly higher proportion of borrowings than equity. Through this acquisition, large amount of shares would be issued to lower the gearing to a healthier standard. Secondly, according to BBC analysis, AIA is the oldest in the region and one of the most profitable. Asians has the highest personal savings rate in the world and the deal would double Pru's customer number. Therefore, although the WACC might be high considering the issue fee and payment to financial firms like FSA, the expected return would successfuly exceed it.
Another example to illustrate the financing capital further is the Four Seasons Health Care, UK's largeast care home provider. Four Seasons must pay back £780m debt in September 2012, which has already dued in last year, and it is talking with investors to try to attract £250m. It has £1.4bn short-term debt in 2006 when it was bought by Qatar Investment Authority in 2006. In last two years, it continued borrowing debt to take over 140 South Corss's homes. During its booming years before crash of 2007/08, it heaped huge debt because it was incredibly cheap to borrow. For private equity firms, there were huge fiannacial incentives to strip assets from a business by replacing equity with debt. Then it suffered refinancing to pay debt these years. (BBC News, 2012)
I think taking over so many homes of South Cross is not a good idea considering its debt situation. Corporations should also considering the risk of the future paument when WACC is relatively low. For example, debt risk could be spreaded by borrowing different types and large different time periods of debt. Companies can also try other products in equity and bond market to prevent over-geared capital structure.
Another example to illustrate the financing capital further is the Four Seasons Health Care, UK's largeast care home provider. Four Seasons must pay back £780m debt in September 2012, which has already dued in last year, and it is talking with investors to try to attract £250m. It has £1.4bn short-term debt in 2006 when it was bought by Qatar Investment Authority in 2006. In last two years, it continued borrowing debt to take over 140 South Corss's homes. During its booming years before crash of 2007/08, it heaped huge debt because it was incredibly cheap to borrow. For private equity firms, there were huge fiannacial incentives to strip assets from a business by replacing equity with debt. Then it suffered refinancing to pay debt these years. (BBC News, 2012)
I think taking over so many homes of South Cross is not a good idea considering its debt situation. Corporations should also considering the risk of the future paument when WACC is relatively low. For example, debt risk could be spreaded by borrowing different types and large different time periods of debt. Companies can also try other products in equity and bond market to prevent over-geared capital structure.
Debts are a good way to raise capital with low cost, and the readjust the debt structure would help the company to reduce the risk level. However, do you think the company have to take the situation in account? The world is in the trouble of financial crisis, and cash becomes very important to company. High gearing could decrease company's cash ability.
ReplyDeletePlease give me some comments, plz!
ReplyDeleteYes!I do think that too much debt would bring an unhealthy capital structure,and may increase corporates' burden day by day. The 2 cases I identified are about the troubles of large amounts of debt bills. Their cash liquidity are already low when they faced such situation.
Delete